PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
Moderator: mart
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
Just noticed the release date for the Voyager 7" is 4th December! That's ages away, I'm guessing the release will be accompanied by the news of the new album.
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
So.. Is this genuine? https://music.apple.com/us/album/doom-a ... 6809530809
Doom and the Dooms
12 Ensemble, Sean Shibe, PJ Harvey, GBSR Duo
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
We're overdue for a PJH/John Parish collaboration.
It was 13 years after the 1996 collab Dance Hall at Louse Point that 2009's A Man A Woman Walked By came out.
It was 13 years after the 1996 collab Dance Hall at Louse Point that 2009's A Man A Woman Walked By came out.
- TheNightingale
- Confirmed User
- Posts: 588
- Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2016 2:23 pm
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
Weird. She is credited in the metadata for this album on a bunch of different streamers (Apple Music, Amazon Music, Shazam – which I think uses the same source as the former as it is owned by Apple) but there is no press release that would mention her involvement in this project. I would write it off a tagging error if she hadn’t put a track by Sean Shibe on her last playlist – this suggests she was listening to his music so a collaboration is not out of the realm of possibility? Weird to learn of it this way, though.Romario11 wrote: Thu Oct 08, 2026 2:01 pm So.. Is this genuine? https://music.apple.com/us/album/doom-a ... 6809530809
Doom and the Dooms
12 Ensemble, Sean Shibe, PJ Harvey, GBSR Duo
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
Confirmed in the comment section on Sean Shibe's instagram accountTheNightingale wrote: Sat Oct 10, 2026 11:56 amWeird. She is credited in the metadata for this album on a bunch of different streamers (Apple Music, Amazon Music, Shazam – which I think uses the same source as the former as it is owned by Apple) but there is no press release that would mention her involvement in this project. I would write it off a tagging error if she hadn’t put a track by Sean Shibe on her last playlist – this suggests she was listening to his music so a collaboration is not out of the realm of possibility? Weird to learn of it this way, though.Romario11 wrote: Thu Oct 08, 2026 2:01 pm So.. Is this genuine? https://music.apple.com/us/album/doom-a ... 6809530809
Doom and the Dooms
12 Ensemble, Sean Shibe, PJ Harvey, GBSR Duo
PJ is credited with additional vocals on these 2 songs, but could be anyone tbh!
- TheNightingale
- Confirmed User
- Posts: 588
- Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2016 2:23 pm
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
Oh, that’s cool, thanks! It’s true that these BVs are pretty anonymous-sounding but it’s nice to see her being a bit more collaborative and working with other musicians.
-
Sebastiano Boina
- Confirmed User
- Posts: 310
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2022 4:48 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
I've just finished listening to the album. It's a weird thing, really. Some tracks are better than others, but i do agree they all sound anonymous. Polly's major and provable contribution apparentely was talking in a couple of tracks ( title not known and incomplete and the Abider) and humming in some others. Maybe she played some instruments, even though she isn't credited for it. At first i was hoping for some weird baroque-sounding and doomsday-themed mirabilia, but alas i was mistaken. It is what it is.
as they say, good things come in threes, so hopefully PJ and JP will make a final collab album one day. I genuinely hope so.DrDark wrote: Fri Oct 09, 2026 5:26 am We're overdue for a PJH/John Parish collaboration.
It was 13 years after the 1996 collab Dance Hall at Louse Point that 2009's A Man A Woman Walked By came out.
-
gwhitlock64
- Confirmed User
- Posts: 5
- Joined: Thu Oct 22, 2026 2:55 pm
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
reckon its a bit of a stretch to call this a proper PJ record if her bits are mostly humming and a bit of talking. not sure how well that sort of cameo works, to be fair, you end up with a name on the sleeve and nowt much to show for it. bit like me getting credited on a bike rebuild cos i held the torch for ten minutes lol
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
No one has said it's a new PJ record, but this was probably the most appropriate thread to mention it
- Hell and High Water
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1951
- Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2009 2:30 am
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
I found this at pjharvey.net -
Composer Oliver Leith has released a new album, Doom and the Dooms. Recreated from tapes found at a garage sale, the project features Sean Shibe, GBSR Duo and 12 Ensemble, with contributions from PJ Harvey.
Polly has been a fan of Oliver’s work for many years and has since become a friend, so it was a great honour for her to be a part of it.
Polly says: “From the first moment I heard Doom and the Dooms on the radio as a child, their music went inside me. I was inspired to get closer to what it is that they were. They had a melancholic longing within their songs – songs full of sadness, but also of joy. I feel my own work has been trying to replicate that feeling ever since.”
https://pjharvey.net/news/oliver-leith- ... the-dooms/
There is a link on the page to a trailer for Doom and the Dooms.
Composer Oliver Leith has released a new album, Doom and the Dooms. Recreated from tapes found at a garage sale, the project features Sean Shibe, GBSR Duo and 12 Ensemble, with contributions from PJ Harvey.
Polly has been a fan of Oliver’s work for many years and has since become a friend, so it was a great honour for her to be a part of it.
Polly says: “From the first moment I heard Doom and the Dooms on the radio as a child, their music went inside me. I was inspired to get closer to what it is that they were. They had a melancholic longing within their songs – songs full of sadness, but also of joy. I feel my own work has been trying to replicate that feeling ever since.”
https://pjharvey.net/news/oliver-leith- ... the-dooms/
There is a link on the page to a trailer for Doom and the Dooms.
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
a long feature with PJH, includes a bit about her new album
https://www.anothermag.com/another-man/ ... -pj-harvey
Damien Jalet in Conversation With PJ Harvey
The invite came out of the blue: “PJ Harvey would like to invite you to her concert.” A lifelong fan of her work, Damien Jalet froze up a little. “Wait, does PJ know me?” Soon after, Jalet and Harvey struck up a friendship beyond the simple pleasantries of two great artists orbiting each other.
From that first meeting, the intersections between their interests were both obvious and deeply strange: a childhood obsession with puppets, for example, and the writings of the American astronomer Carl Sagan. They also share the same fears — namely, the feeling when approaching a new project that it could all so easily go very wrong. What draws Harvey to Jalet’s work the most, as well as to her own love of performing live, is its ephemerality: the idea of gathering people in a space to share something intimate, only for it to be gone forever. “There’s nothing more beautiful than that,” she says.
PJ Harvey I’m an artist, and I’m fascinated by how other artists work and how they go about developing an idea. Where does the idea come from? But before all that, I’m just curious to know: at what age did you first start wanting to make things, and when did that develop into wanting to make things using your body? Do you remember when that began?
Damien Jalet I mean, literally, my very first memory is connected to performance, because performance is really my topic.
PJH Was there always a burning need to perform? I mean, from as soon as you can remember?
DJ When I was three, my parents brought me to see a puppet show. It was the most ridiculous puppet show because they did all the classics, but with a Belgian accent. They brought me to watch Faust, and at one point, the devil came on stage. The devil was not a puppet; it was actually a man ten times bigger than the puppet, dressed in red. Most kids were scared, but I was just clapping my hands out of excitement because of the power of this person coming on.
PJH Because of the power of this person coming on?
DJ I don’t know. I guess it connected to something that resonated with me. Maybe there was something spectacular about it, or something that challenged my perception of things. The next day, I was playing with my mother’s red napkin as if it were curtains, and every time there was a large staircase, it immediately became a stage, and I would always need to perform. But I was only three or four. So I’ve always remembered that need, in a way, to be a performer. Although I don’t really consider myself a performer anymore, because I tend to do one thing at a time. It’s hard for me to be both a director and a performer. I tried, but performing always felt incredibly natural.
PJH So it started with this love of performance.
DJ Yeah, something about that space where you can transform, where you can become someone else. Theatre was my first love. I was actually going to become a director. My first studies were at a national school of theatre (in Brussels) as a director, and I would perform there as well. I was already keen to direct, but theatre was my first love because I think there was this idea of transformation and becoming someone else. And I see that completely in your work as well, because I think each album is a character, and each song is a different personality.
PJH We used to have a man come and do puppet shows on our birthdays. They were string puppets, marionette puppets, and he’d come with a stage. After that, I made my own stage out of cardboard boxes. I bought string puppets and made hand puppets, and I would write plays that I would perform to my family on my stage. I’d go behind the stage and be the puppeteer.
DJ It’s so sweet. I had a puppet theatre too, and I also had a crocodile. When I was at the national school, I used it for my very first breakthrough in directing. It was an exercise we had to do: adapt a text we loved into a performance. I had done something about childhood and the very first memory that you have. We often present childhood as something sweet and nice, but actually it is the place of the first trauma, the first pain, the first fear. I had done something with one of my colleagues at the time. We made it a solo with her, with a lot of elements, and then there was this puppet with a crocodile. I remember that I was already really into animals, and very much into the monstrous aspect of them. I mean, connected to the devil, there was this uncanniness. If you look at the works I do now, there are a lot of monsters in them. I find it so amazing that we have that connection with puppets. But how did it then become music?
PJH Well, I started writing plays for the puppets to perform. I’d write stories and plays with all the dialogue for them to say, and then I’d perform these shows. My family were the only people who watched them, but then that sort of carried on. One of my first memories is having this little book. I was, I guess, about five. I could just about write and draw, so the book had lines at the bottom to write in and a blank bit at the top to draw in. I carried it everywhere with me, making a drawing and making a story about the drawing. It was mostly to do with animals because I lived in the countryside on a farm. So I’d draw the animals and write about them, make poems, then make plays and turn them into puppet shows. I just know that, even at that young age, it was somewhere I felt really peaceful, like I’d found my home. In my day-to-day life, I found it really hard to express myself. I was a very shy person. I felt sort of squashed by the world and unable to break through. Yet within this little book, with my drawings and my puppets, I had a voice that just flowed out of me. So it was like a salvation for me at a really young age.
DJ It was a kind of catharsis. You could just become or express feelings that you couldn’t otherwise express through those things. I just think it was an –
PJH Outlet, not so much a catharsis. I don’t think it changed the problem in any way, but it meant that there was at least somewhere I could utterly express myself freely.
DJ And each time you get into an album, because you are also kind of the queen of reinvention. I came to your music when I was around 20, that’s when I started to get really into what you do. And I think in each of them there is an exploration of one topic, one world, one condition. I always found it amazing how you could take the perspective, the voice, a little bit like a shaman who would transform into different characters. You know that film Rashomon by Kurosawa? I love it so much. There’s this moment where you see that truth is never objective, but you can actually find it. It’s basically a story of a triangle in a forest where there’s a murder, and each of the characters is on trial and expressing their different opinions. At one point, the shaman takes the voice of the husband who was killed. I love the idea that truth is actually not objective. It’s always subjective, but shared from different perspectives.
PJH I think I’ve always needed and wanted to explore different ways of making things – for me, music, poetry, but different ways. How can I do something different? Because I’m so interested in learning. I just don’t want to keep doing something that I know I can do because I’ve done it before. So I always want to put myself in a position where I’ve got to find a new way to say something or present something, because I’m purely so excited by that. I just want that excitement of going into the unknown all the time, and I sort of measure it by how scared I feel.
DJ I so relate. Each time I’m going to start a creation, I’m terrified. The week before I start, I behave erratically, calling my friends, trying to find an exit. This is also because there’s a difference between us in the fact that ITimmediately start with people in the studio, and they are my tools – they are, ina sense, my collaborators. So all the eyes are kind of turned towards whatever you want. You don’t always choose them, because sometimes you work for a company where they are, but they are the people who are going to transmit your creation. There is something very fragile about that place to be in, because it’s a position of authority in a way. I don’t like to use that word, but you need to lead, and in that sense –
PJH So that’s the frightening part?
DJ Well, the frightening part is this idea of the unknown. For me, I want that. I don’t want to know what I’m going to create, and whatever creation you start needs to feel like the exploration of a landscape that you haven’t been to before.
PJH But do you go in with an idea? So you'll have a general idea about it, or maybe even a title? Like, “I want to make a piece about this subject.” Will you go in with as much as that prepared?
DJ I need to have a departure point, for sure, and I’m trying to create a frame, a kind of canvas. I mean, there’s a book for a writer; there’s a frame for a painter as well. When you make a film, you also have that frame. But I love to define certain limits and just create the kind of rules of a game that I would invite people to play with me. I think when I approach it, I start with an idea. Obviously, I often love to collaborate with someone, whether it’s a visual artist, composer, designer, or someone else, because the conversation that we would have even before I start with the dancers would already define the research ground. Like, where are we going to go?
PJH And it will also bring different ideas. But where does the initial idea come from?
DJ That’s always kind of a mystery.
PJH I know.
DJ Talking with you about the creative process, I realised that we were a little bit equal in those things, because that’s, for me, the most terrifying part: the start. The first week is always the hardest, whatever the process. Because at one point, when you start establishing certain rules, and everybody starts participating and giving part of themselves to the process, then there is a certain dynamic. There’s maybe a certain kind of spiral that starts. It’s like an –
PJH Energy.
DJ An energy that starts to limit the construction. I often find myself in the last week, even if the last week is always very hard because you have to finish everything on time, it’s a little bit like a baby that has its own needs and knows what you need to give it most of the time. It can be chaotic until the end, but there’s usually a certain point where you understand there’s a vacuum, and the piece is demanding something. It’s much easier to feed it. But at the beginning, you need to define those rules.
PJH It’s really similar for me. When I find my idea and I start a project, I'll go through the most painful period, sometimes months on end, before it starts to show me how it needs to be. For instance, I’m working on a new album now, and I probably wrote for eight months before I found something usable. Then I found one song that was like, “Oh my God, there it is,” and it took me that long. Once that song came, I knew where I was going. And when I have been in an environment where I’m improvising with people, it is a really big thrill for me. I did that for the first time ever in late 2024. I improvised with Nils Frahm for four days from nothing. I’d never improvised with anyone because I think I’d always been scared of it. I’d gotten set in my pattern of how I work, which is that I work alone until the end, until the songs are in a demo form, and then I go into the studio with others. But to go into a studio with nothing and one other person, I found it one of the most exciting times of my life. But I was utterly exhausted because every day we were just trying to make something out of nothing. We'd have some days where nothing came, and we were both exhausted, and actually no one had a good idea. Then you get days where five amazing ideas all happen at once.
DJ It’s a process, a synergy. I mean, I’m very used to what you describe because, as I say, I hardly ever do things by myself.
PJH Have you ever, in the past?
DJ I was a performer for other people, and I was always performing the work of others. When I performed my own work, I was kind of hiding myself. You would hardly see my face. I’ve always not been afraid of extreme exposure, but at the same time I’m very secretive and shy.
PJH That’s really interesting to me because, again, even when I was really little, I needed to perform in front of people. I can remember when I was small, just thinking, “Look at me, look at me, I’m performing.” People would get bored: “Look at me.” But I really needed to be the one on the stage that people were looking at, because I needed to tell stories. Did you have that?
DJ Yes, I was exactly the same at a young age, and I felt like that during my 20 years of dancing on stage nearly every night in front of an audience. I was a fullon performer, dancing a lot but also sometimes singing medieval polyphonies, acting, performing all over the world. When I was on stage, I would wear the red suit and call for attention.
PJH So why not now? Why did it change?
DJ It’s funny. It’s still the same job in a way because it’s still about giving life to a world and trying to connect to that invisible place, that subconscious place. It’s about trying to give a coherency, or a homage, whatever you want to call it, to the experience of life. But at one point, maybe because I danced so much, I didn’t really have that necessity to perform. At least for now. It might come back suddenly, like a kind of dancing plague. Maybe it’s still possible. I just know that I have this capacity. Maybe what’s interesting is that, as a dancer, my mother wouldn’t want to come to see me anymore because she thought that I would hurt myself. I was always hurting myself before because I would go to extremes. I would do things like lotus positions; they would play football with my head. I would do things that were really quite painful to watch, very visceral, and it would sap all of my energy. It’s already so demanding on every single level to do this and to pay attention to every single detail, to be truthful to the vision you have, to be truthful to the collaborators you have. I found it nearly impossible for me to do both. I need two bodies to do that, and I guess I only have one.
PJH Does physicality come into play? Obviously, as we get older and our bodies change, you’re an athlete. Does it limit your practice? Is that part of why you wouldn’t perform as much? I question things myself because, as my body gets older, I have to change the way I perform too, because I can’t ask the same of my body as I could as a younger woman.
DJ Yeah. I think I was probably used to always waking up sore, and I still feel the mark of my dancing in my body.
PJH Do you still have pains?
DJ Not really, because I always moved in an incredibly organic way. I came late to dance. I started when I saw Madonna when I was 11; she connected me to that kind of energy. But I really started to do it seriously when I was 19 or 20, and that’s when I switched completely from theatre to dance. Through this medium, I started working back with all the other mediums – cinema, theatre, visual art, music, fashion – because dance has that capacity for conversing with all of them. Which is the best, because you can cross not just physical or cultural borders, but also artistic and medium borders, and that makes it incredibly enriching. But I don’t know. My body is fine. I don’t think that was the decision for me to stop performing. I just think that I was called, suddenly. I’ve seen you performing recently, and I was so stunned by the precision and the shape-shifting nature of your performance, and how you could suddenly go into things that were very physical and others that were incredibly static and meditative, while also playing all these instruments. But I know the stamina of dancing, and when you have all that energy, it’s not just about singing or playing instruments, or making sure that your band is in tune with what you do, but also that the visuals are working and so on. How does that feel for you to perform when you’re on stage?
PJH Well I worked with a theatre director on my show, Ian Rickson, who I’ve worked with for the last three shows since Let England Shake. I'd done music for his plays, and I found it so fascinating watching how Ian would direct the actors, but how he’d lean into what they were naturally doing and enhance the strength of that. So I began working with Ian on my show. Ian would come to the rehearsals, he’d listen to the demos of the songs, and he’d start to feel the emotional thread that was going through them. Being a theatre director, he thinks a lot in narrative – the narrative arc of this night, of this hour-and-a-half performance. He helps me find a way through that. He would watch what I naturally wanted to do in terms of singing and movement, and he would enhance what he thought were the good bits, tone down the bits that he thought were the bad bits, and get me connecting with the band regularly.
DJ Did he direct you in the movements as well?
PJH For instance, I was opening with my hands going like this (gestures). I was naturally doing that. But then he’d do things like, “Where is your head looking? Are you looking up? Are the hands going up? Looking down? Looking to the side? Drawing within yourself?” I love working with him, and I love the world of theatre. But just going back to dance as well, I think of all the other mediums of performance, I get the most inspiration from dance. I think it’s because there are no words, and I love that my imagination is set free by what this performance is saying to me with no words. It’s just saying it with bodies, music, set design and lighting, and it’s making me feel something really intensely. No one’s telling me what to feel.
DJ It’s a space of freedom, I would say. That’s also very much true for me. I think I would not have become a choreographer if I hadn’t followed the logic and principles of contemporary dance, because I’ve always had an issue with the very dogmatic and extremely strict nature, for example, of ballet. Even though I ended up working with ballet later, there’s something in me that really doesn’t connect with the way I see dance and why I love it. I love the fact that dance can be a place that invents its own rules. It’s an incredibly difficult process as well, but there is a sense of freedom that I love in contemporary dance. Maybe because it is so tuned in, it also merges with music. It’s such an intimate relationship with music because it plays with space and time in ways that mean you can basically reinvent it. You reinvent your relationship to it. I really use that non-dogmatic, non-traditional opportunity that was there, and that’s why I left theatre to go into dance, because I saw that there was this space of freedom that could be created.
PJH For me, I think the greatest reward is when I’ve taken a lot of time, care and love, and tried to make something as good as I possibly can, and then see how much it brings to other people. When you see how much people are physically moved by it, how much it enters their lives and changes them, there’s no better feeling than knowing that something I really tended to and cared for can do that for others. I think when we’ve made a piece and it goes out into the world, it’s no longer ours. It goes out for the people who are going to come and see it. It’s easy to ask yourself, “Why am I doing this?” Sometimes you can think, “What is this for? How important is it as an artist?” We live in today’s world where politics are governing the way we operate, and for the likes of you and me, as artists, we don’t get to have a lot of sway in how people run our world. And yet we keep trying to make these pieces of work that touch people and move people. Is our hope, when we’re talking about water and the waves, that these ripples of our small-scale work, seen by relatively few people in the world, and possibly by people who already feel and think like us, are going to have any sort of impact on the wider world – the world that we might hope to affect and change? That’s a question for both of us.
DJ The butterfly effect of this thing – a very small thing – can have a tremendous impact, but you’re not necessarily aware of it. Now, with the internet, certain things go viral and spread and get seen by a lot of people. The thing that is closest to the scale of what you’ve experienced during your whole career was the thing I did recently with Yung Lean, where suddenly I could feel that the whole world was enthusiastic about what this dance was conveying.
PJH That’s amazing, that the work you did with him, which started on such a small level, reached so many people. I find that so exciting, and that’s still the hope that I think I have inside.
DJ I was really surprised by how many people it touched, and how deeply. It’s just three minutes of movement and a song. But I think music, dance and literature, especially at this time when we feel incredibly threatened as a civilisation, but also as a species, because we’re dealing with incredible challenges that no generation before us has experienced, mean that art takes on even more of that role now: to remind us what is at the core expression of our soul. It connects again to the Voyager and this idea that what they sent into space as a first signal for aliens to see of us, is music. That tells me everything, in the sense that this is the core of our soul. Dance comes maybe a little bit after, or maybe quite a lot after. It’s so ephemeral. I think I’m really jealous of musicians, who have this sense of waves. You are tuned into invisible waves that can be accessed everywhere, at any time.
PJH We both try to make work that is about the world that we all share. We’re not just making intimate pieces about ourselves. We’re looking outwards because we care, and then the care that we take at that inception level of the idea ...
DJ It’s like a virus. It can be transmitted, that’s why you say something is going viral. I was in Japan during the earthquake in 2011, and I learned a great lesson there, because the Japanese were so incredibly calm throughout the whole apocalyptic situation. I remember each time there was an aftershock, we foreigners were like, “Oh my God!” We were running and trying to check what was happening; we were in complete panic, while they remained incredibly calm. I thought, as much as panic is contagious, calm and dignity are as well. We should never forget that we have that ambivalence inside of us, and there is constantly a question of how we can transmit values that are actually going to make things better.
PJH I think that’s a brilliant thing to say, and I think that’s also the hope that we carry in the work that we make: that it will resonate and affect people in that way, and move people towards a different path, maybe.
DJ For me, when I got into the lyrics of your new song, I felt an incredible sense of connection. To come back to when we met, I literally received a message from your manager when I was in Japan saying, “PJ Harvey would like to invite you to her concert.” I was like, “Wait, does PJ Harvey know me?” I couldn’t really process it. But then, when we actually met, you told me that you had come to see my shows five years before. I was so stunned. I thought, “How was I not aware that you were there and that you had so discreetly come to see the work?” Then we started talking about the work I was doing on Carl Sagan and Planet, and then we talked about Voyager and Tim Hecker. You told me that you loved Tim Hecker and that you were really interested in the Golden Record on Voyager. I was like, “Wow, these are incredibly specific interests.” So when I listened to the song “Voyager” I thought, “Wow, it really portrays something that I truly went through when I was making that work.” I think this idea that Carl Sagan had – to put these records on a spacecraft so that an extraterrestrial entity could intercept them and eventually receive a portrait of humanity through music – is incredible. It’s so poetic, yet it was conceived by scientists, and it’s so transcendent as well. For me, the discovery of the Golden Record profoundly inspired the process I went through on Planet, because I was looking for fossils, in a sense, for how we could give a perspective on humanity from another point of view than the one we have now. Sometimes we can get that perspective by studying history, finding fossils of previous civilisations, or even looking at life from billions of years ago. There’s this fascination that humanity has, but also this need that humans have to wander and go beyond their own borders, and the nostalgia that humans had when they finally went to the Moon. Then you look at the pale blue dot and feel that everything we know is contained on this very limited planet, while the rest is basically a void, and life itself is in jeopardy everywhere. I felt that this was an incredibly relevant point of view to have nowadays, given the time we are living through as humans. We’ve done so many things, but we’ve also caused so much harm, with a sense of unawareness about where we come from and our place within a very fragile web of life. How did you compose that song, and how did it become that incredibly emotional crescendo?
PJH I was already, as you know, really interested in our place within this enormous universe when we first met, and I think naturally, as you get older, you think about those things more. At this time in my life, I really wanted to learn about astrophysics and our solar system. I’m fascinated by finding out more, and in doing so, discovering how tiny we are, and how briefly we’re here. There’s something very humbling about that, in a really good way, when you’re living your daily life. Just remember that every day. I was already on that trajectory when Brian Cox asked me to write a song for his new live lecture. He asked me to write it as if I were Voyager 2, as if I were the voice of Voyager 2 speaking to the people on Earth based on what I had seen, and I loved that idea. He came up with it because when he first asked me about making a song, I was already writing music for my new album, and there were a few pieces I wasn’t sure were quite right. I thought I’d see if Brian liked any of them because I didn’t think I was going to use them. One of those pieces was made on a synthesiser, and it had a signal that was a bit like Morse code, or like a signal being sent back to Earth. That made Brian think of the signal from the Voyager 2 spacecraft and the way it sends information back to us, and because he talks a lot about the Voyager space probes in his lecture, he thought it would be perfect. So that’s how it began. But I’d already done a lot of research because I had basically watched and read everything that Carl Sagan had done, so I knew a lot about it already. I think it’s wonderful that he pushed through to get the Golden Records put on those spacecraft. How beautiful that there was this desire to send something from our world out into possibly nothing, but the desire was there to show a little bit of who we are and how we communicate. I love that there were greetings from all across the world, and especially the one spoken by Carl Sagan’s son. It was so intimate and yet so vast, all at the same time. The song flowed from me because I was already so deeply into the subject, and then being given the challenge that it had to be this voice and this spacecraft somehow, with those limitations, made it much easier to write because I knew exactly what I had to work with. It seems to me that you’re forever travelling, forever working really hard in stressful environments. Do you find it stressful, or do you thrive on it? Does it actually energise you?
DJ Well, in a way, it’s like a ritual. It creates a kind of bracket in time, and within that time it gives you pressure. In a sense, I try to use that as something that activates my resources and my imagination. It’s a little bit like the conversation we’re having now. Out of this conversation, certain ideas emerge.
PJH I think we both agree that we’re not quite sure where ideas come from. This fascinates me, because I know where the drive comes from. We both have the drive to make. We make stuff, and we have to make things. There’s really no question about it. I think you feel the same. Where does that come from? Personally I really don’t know, and I don’t know if you do either. Let England Shake was during the time of the Iraq War and the Afghan War, and I was watching a documentary about a young soldier who had been so badly damaged that he would never be able to continue his life. It was an intimate documentary about how that had affected him and his family, and there was something about this man and his family that moved me to tears. I remember crying while watching it. At the time, I was trying to think, “What am I going to write about next?” I’d come off White Chalk, which had been a very intimate album. I knew I wanted to go in the opposite direction. I wanted to move somewhere further away from that, to do something different. I wanted to look out into the world, and I thought to myself, “Polly, if you’re this moved by watching this, write about that.”
DJ Well, I think it’s so interesting because what you’re describing is that you took as a departure point where the previous album had brought you, and then you thought, “No, I want to move out of that situation.” You contextualise everything from that. I mean, every work I do is an exploration. I become aware of certain aspects of a condition through the creation itself. When you create a work, you start... it’s like a prism. You watch everything through a certain glass, a certain perspective. My last creation was actually called Prism. Through that exploration, there are a lot of things you discover, and those eventually lead you to take certain directions in your work. For example, when we did Vessel with Kohei Nawa, it emerged first from a desire to really work with him. He was my departure point. There was something I found so fascinating in his work, and then he agreed to collaborate. Basically, he started finding what I created incredibly inspiring for his own work, and that’s why I love collaboration. In a way, it emerges a bit like what we’re doing now, from a conversation. One thing leads you through the conversation, and you start understanding what the nucleus of a common interest is.
PJH I think it’s also how we find each other. You know, I reached out to you because there was something in your work that moved me so much that I felt I had to meet you. I had to meet this person because it felt like a compulsion.
DJ It’s very interesting, this contrast between seeds of ideas that emerge in an intimate life and then become so universal. I love exploring the subconscious. I try to pay attention to ideas that sometimes emerge in the moment between when you fall asleep and when you wake up. I always think of it like this idea in Tarkovsky – that we come from the sea as organisms, that our origin is there, in water. Water moves in a very specific way. I think one of the most inspiring movements for me is water because it’s constantly shape-shifting. It can freeze; it can be extremely quiet; it can be incredibly violent. It’s literally the main component of our life. Even if we don’t live in water, we still carry it like vessels. I find this really interesting because water is often seen as a symbol of death. There’s this idea of crossing a river when you die in so many mythologies, and at the same time it’s also considered, scientifically, the cradle of life. So I find this metaphor incredibly inspiring, and I think when you wake up, it’s a little bit like arriving ashore. Suddenly, you were in that kind of wavy environment, and you became conscious. I always take the image of someone who comes out of an ocean and wakes up, and you have a bit of that feeling of, “Oh, you get back to your body.”
PJH Yeah, I agree. I think coming out of sleep is like emerging from being underwater. But also, the images that you get in that halfsleep, half-awake state are so rich for creating with. I’m sure you’re someone who remembers every dream you have, don’t you?
DJ No, I don’t.
PJH You don’t?
DJ Do you?
PJH Yes! I don’t take notes. I never write a song out of dreams, but I remember every dream vividly.
DJ I know if I dream vividly, and I know I can have very emotional dreams, things that really get to your core. What I have sometimes is that, when I sleep and I’m falling asleep, my physical memory – the smell of the pillow, the horizontality – brings me to the dream of the previous night. It’s like a physical memory. It’s interesting that when you take the same position, when you feel the same texture, suddenly your body brings it back.
PJH That’s so interesting. I love that you said that because, and being a dancer, you would. You’re right. I have to get into the same position every night to feel safe enough to go to sleep, and I’ll wake up in the same position. That’s something really primal, I think, and goes right back to the womb – needing a feeling of safety to let yourself lose consciousness.
DJ It’s also the idea that gravity, when you fall asleep, that’s literally falling. You surrender. It’s one of the only moments when you have to let go.
PJH Apart from having sex.
DJ Yes, but even love – you can also fall in love and you can crash in love. And ultimately, sex is obviously when you really surrender. But, for example, it’s impossible to have sex in space. Did you ever hear that?
PJH Why?
DJ Because there’s no gravity.
PJH Oh, so you know what? I think that would be the funniest comedy sketch ever: to see two people in space trying to have sex.
DJ Nobody has done it yet.
PJH That’s really interesting. I think both of our work has a lot of sexuality in it. We’re absolutely right in that I think there’s nothing more vulnerable, including sleep, when you have to surrender consciousness. Where do we go? We go into this place where we have no control, and yet sex and intimacy can be like that too.
DJ So, just to finish this thing with ideas, I think David Lynch said that you need to compare ideas to fish, that you need to go and catch the big fish.
PJH Catching the big fish.
DJ So, that idea again – there is a connection. I think the subconscious moves like an ocean in a way, and I really see that sometimes when we allow ourselves to plunge into it. There are different ways of doing that. For example, if you think of altered states of consciousness, which are basically ways of reaching the subconscious, sleeping would be one of the greatest moments of surrendering to it. But daydreaming, when you’re suddenly looking into the void and starting to think of something that absorbs you, is another. It’s not something that you see; it’s something that you see beyond, or that you imagine. It’s somehow a way to connect yourself to that world. So I think it has to do with something like that. I’ve always been surprised that a lot of ideas emerge and sometimes I just have to catch them, but it’s not me that produces them.
PJH Yeah, I think David Lynch was talking about that because of his transcendental meditation as well. Through meditation, when you lose the boundaries of consciousness and set yourself free, I think that’s where you can go fishing for ideas. But you have to free yourself into it, like what you’re saying about daydreaming – giving yourself permission to let your brain swim freely without being hemmed in by our usual, agitated worries about the past or the future. I think it’s something that you can learn, and I know David Lynch was a practising meditator. You can learn a better way of finding your ideas through that. But I do think it’s really powerful, and it all comes back to consciousness and how we allow it or disallow it.
https://www.anothermag.com/another-man/ ... -pj-harvey
Damien Jalet in Conversation With PJ Harvey
The invite came out of the blue: “PJ Harvey would like to invite you to her concert.” A lifelong fan of her work, Damien Jalet froze up a little. “Wait, does PJ know me?” Soon after, Jalet and Harvey struck up a friendship beyond the simple pleasantries of two great artists orbiting each other.
From that first meeting, the intersections between their interests were both obvious and deeply strange: a childhood obsession with puppets, for example, and the writings of the American astronomer Carl Sagan. They also share the same fears — namely, the feeling when approaching a new project that it could all so easily go very wrong. What draws Harvey to Jalet’s work the most, as well as to her own love of performing live, is its ephemerality: the idea of gathering people in a space to share something intimate, only for it to be gone forever. “There’s nothing more beautiful than that,” she says.
PJ Harvey I’m an artist, and I’m fascinated by how other artists work and how they go about developing an idea. Where does the idea come from? But before all that, I’m just curious to know: at what age did you first start wanting to make things, and when did that develop into wanting to make things using your body? Do you remember when that began?
Damien Jalet I mean, literally, my very first memory is connected to performance, because performance is really my topic.
PJH Was there always a burning need to perform? I mean, from as soon as you can remember?
DJ When I was three, my parents brought me to see a puppet show. It was the most ridiculous puppet show because they did all the classics, but with a Belgian accent. They brought me to watch Faust, and at one point, the devil came on stage. The devil was not a puppet; it was actually a man ten times bigger than the puppet, dressed in red. Most kids were scared, but I was just clapping my hands out of excitement because of the power of this person coming on.
PJH Because of the power of this person coming on?
DJ I don’t know. I guess it connected to something that resonated with me. Maybe there was something spectacular about it, or something that challenged my perception of things. The next day, I was playing with my mother’s red napkin as if it were curtains, and every time there was a large staircase, it immediately became a stage, and I would always need to perform. But I was only three or four. So I’ve always remembered that need, in a way, to be a performer. Although I don’t really consider myself a performer anymore, because I tend to do one thing at a time. It’s hard for me to be both a director and a performer. I tried, but performing always felt incredibly natural.
PJH So it started with this love of performance.
DJ Yeah, something about that space where you can transform, where you can become someone else. Theatre was my first love. I was actually going to become a director. My first studies were at a national school of theatre (in Brussels) as a director, and I would perform there as well. I was already keen to direct, but theatre was my first love because I think there was this idea of transformation and becoming someone else. And I see that completely in your work as well, because I think each album is a character, and each song is a different personality.
PJH We used to have a man come and do puppet shows on our birthdays. They were string puppets, marionette puppets, and he’d come with a stage. After that, I made my own stage out of cardboard boxes. I bought string puppets and made hand puppets, and I would write plays that I would perform to my family on my stage. I’d go behind the stage and be the puppeteer.
DJ It’s so sweet. I had a puppet theatre too, and I also had a crocodile. When I was at the national school, I used it for my very first breakthrough in directing. It was an exercise we had to do: adapt a text we loved into a performance. I had done something about childhood and the very first memory that you have. We often present childhood as something sweet and nice, but actually it is the place of the first trauma, the first pain, the first fear. I had done something with one of my colleagues at the time. We made it a solo with her, with a lot of elements, and then there was this puppet with a crocodile. I remember that I was already really into animals, and very much into the monstrous aspect of them. I mean, connected to the devil, there was this uncanniness. If you look at the works I do now, there are a lot of monsters in them. I find it so amazing that we have that connection with puppets. But how did it then become music?
PJH Well, I started writing plays for the puppets to perform. I’d write stories and plays with all the dialogue for them to say, and then I’d perform these shows. My family were the only people who watched them, but then that sort of carried on. One of my first memories is having this little book. I was, I guess, about five. I could just about write and draw, so the book had lines at the bottom to write in and a blank bit at the top to draw in. I carried it everywhere with me, making a drawing and making a story about the drawing. It was mostly to do with animals because I lived in the countryside on a farm. So I’d draw the animals and write about them, make poems, then make plays and turn them into puppet shows. I just know that, even at that young age, it was somewhere I felt really peaceful, like I’d found my home. In my day-to-day life, I found it really hard to express myself. I was a very shy person. I felt sort of squashed by the world and unable to break through. Yet within this little book, with my drawings and my puppets, I had a voice that just flowed out of me. So it was like a salvation for me at a really young age.
DJ It was a kind of catharsis. You could just become or express feelings that you couldn’t otherwise express through those things. I just think it was an –
PJH Outlet, not so much a catharsis. I don’t think it changed the problem in any way, but it meant that there was at least somewhere I could utterly express myself freely.
DJ And each time you get into an album, because you are also kind of the queen of reinvention. I came to your music when I was around 20, that’s when I started to get really into what you do. And I think in each of them there is an exploration of one topic, one world, one condition. I always found it amazing how you could take the perspective, the voice, a little bit like a shaman who would transform into different characters. You know that film Rashomon by Kurosawa? I love it so much. There’s this moment where you see that truth is never objective, but you can actually find it. It’s basically a story of a triangle in a forest where there’s a murder, and each of the characters is on trial and expressing their different opinions. At one point, the shaman takes the voice of the husband who was killed. I love the idea that truth is actually not objective. It’s always subjective, but shared from different perspectives.
PJH I think I’ve always needed and wanted to explore different ways of making things – for me, music, poetry, but different ways. How can I do something different? Because I’m so interested in learning. I just don’t want to keep doing something that I know I can do because I’ve done it before. So I always want to put myself in a position where I’ve got to find a new way to say something or present something, because I’m purely so excited by that. I just want that excitement of going into the unknown all the time, and I sort of measure it by how scared I feel.
DJ I so relate. Each time I’m going to start a creation, I’m terrified. The week before I start, I behave erratically, calling my friends, trying to find an exit. This is also because there’s a difference between us in the fact that ITimmediately start with people in the studio, and they are my tools – they are, ina sense, my collaborators. So all the eyes are kind of turned towards whatever you want. You don’t always choose them, because sometimes you work for a company where they are, but they are the people who are going to transmit your creation. There is something very fragile about that place to be in, because it’s a position of authority in a way. I don’t like to use that word, but you need to lead, and in that sense –
PJH So that’s the frightening part?
DJ Well, the frightening part is this idea of the unknown. For me, I want that. I don’t want to know what I’m going to create, and whatever creation you start needs to feel like the exploration of a landscape that you haven’t been to before.
PJH But do you go in with an idea? So you'll have a general idea about it, or maybe even a title? Like, “I want to make a piece about this subject.” Will you go in with as much as that prepared?
DJ I need to have a departure point, for sure, and I’m trying to create a frame, a kind of canvas. I mean, there’s a book for a writer; there’s a frame for a painter as well. When you make a film, you also have that frame. But I love to define certain limits and just create the kind of rules of a game that I would invite people to play with me. I think when I approach it, I start with an idea. Obviously, I often love to collaborate with someone, whether it’s a visual artist, composer, designer, or someone else, because the conversation that we would have even before I start with the dancers would already define the research ground. Like, where are we going to go?
PJH And it will also bring different ideas. But where does the initial idea come from?
DJ That’s always kind of a mystery.
PJH I know.
DJ Talking with you about the creative process, I realised that we were a little bit equal in those things, because that’s, for me, the most terrifying part: the start. The first week is always the hardest, whatever the process. Because at one point, when you start establishing certain rules, and everybody starts participating and giving part of themselves to the process, then there is a certain dynamic. There’s maybe a certain kind of spiral that starts. It’s like an –
PJH Energy.
DJ An energy that starts to limit the construction. I often find myself in the last week, even if the last week is always very hard because you have to finish everything on time, it’s a little bit like a baby that has its own needs and knows what you need to give it most of the time. It can be chaotic until the end, but there’s usually a certain point where you understand there’s a vacuum, and the piece is demanding something. It’s much easier to feed it. But at the beginning, you need to define those rules.
PJH It’s really similar for me. When I find my idea and I start a project, I'll go through the most painful period, sometimes months on end, before it starts to show me how it needs to be. For instance, I’m working on a new album now, and I probably wrote for eight months before I found something usable. Then I found one song that was like, “Oh my God, there it is,” and it took me that long. Once that song came, I knew where I was going. And when I have been in an environment where I’m improvising with people, it is a really big thrill for me. I did that for the first time ever in late 2024. I improvised with Nils Frahm for four days from nothing. I’d never improvised with anyone because I think I’d always been scared of it. I’d gotten set in my pattern of how I work, which is that I work alone until the end, until the songs are in a demo form, and then I go into the studio with others. But to go into a studio with nothing and one other person, I found it one of the most exciting times of my life. But I was utterly exhausted because every day we were just trying to make something out of nothing. We'd have some days where nothing came, and we were both exhausted, and actually no one had a good idea. Then you get days where five amazing ideas all happen at once.
DJ It’s a process, a synergy. I mean, I’m very used to what you describe because, as I say, I hardly ever do things by myself.
PJH Have you ever, in the past?
DJ I was a performer for other people, and I was always performing the work of others. When I performed my own work, I was kind of hiding myself. You would hardly see my face. I’ve always not been afraid of extreme exposure, but at the same time I’m very secretive and shy.
PJH That’s really interesting to me because, again, even when I was really little, I needed to perform in front of people. I can remember when I was small, just thinking, “Look at me, look at me, I’m performing.” People would get bored: “Look at me.” But I really needed to be the one on the stage that people were looking at, because I needed to tell stories. Did you have that?
DJ Yes, I was exactly the same at a young age, and I felt like that during my 20 years of dancing on stage nearly every night in front of an audience. I was a fullon performer, dancing a lot but also sometimes singing medieval polyphonies, acting, performing all over the world. When I was on stage, I would wear the red suit and call for attention.
PJH So why not now? Why did it change?
DJ It’s funny. It’s still the same job in a way because it’s still about giving life to a world and trying to connect to that invisible place, that subconscious place. It’s about trying to give a coherency, or a homage, whatever you want to call it, to the experience of life. But at one point, maybe because I danced so much, I didn’t really have that necessity to perform. At least for now. It might come back suddenly, like a kind of dancing plague. Maybe it’s still possible. I just know that I have this capacity. Maybe what’s interesting is that, as a dancer, my mother wouldn’t want to come to see me anymore because she thought that I would hurt myself. I was always hurting myself before because I would go to extremes. I would do things like lotus positions; they would play football with my head. I would do things that were really quite painful to watch, very visceral, and it would sap all of my energy. It’s already so demanding on every single level to do this and to pay attention to every single detail, to be truthful to the vision you have, to be truthful to the collaborators you have. I found it nearly impossible for me to do both. I need two bodies to do that, and I guess I only have one.
PJH Does physicality come into play? Obviously, as we get older and our bodies change, you’re an athlete. Does it limit your practice? Is that part of why you wouldn’t perform as much? I question things myself because, as my body gets older, I have to change the way I perform too, because I can’t ask the same of my body as I could as a younger woman.
DJ Yeah. I think I was probably used to always waking up sore, and I still feel the mark of my dancing in my body.
PJH Do you still have pains?
DJ Not really, because I always moved in an incredibly organic way. I came late to dance. I started when I saw Madonna when I was 11; she connected me to that kind of energy. But I really started to do it seriously when I was 19 or 20, and that’s when I switched completely from theatre to dance. Through this medium, I started working back with all the other mediums – cinema, theatre, visual art, music, fashion – because dance has that capacity for conversing with all of them. Which is the best, because you can cross not just physical or cultural borders, but also artistic and medium borders, and that makes it incredibly enriching. But I don’t know. My body is fine. I don’t think that was the decision for me to stop performing. I just think that I was called, suddenly. I’ve seen you performing recently, and I was so stunned by the precision and the shape-shifting nature of your performance, and how you could suddenly go into things that were very physical and others that were incredibly static and meditative, while also playing all these instruments. But I know the stamina of dancing, and when you have all that energy, it’s not just about singing or playing instruments, or making sure that your band is in tune with what you do, but also that the visuals are working and so on. How does that feel for you to perform when you’re on stage?
PJH Well I worked with a theatre director on my show, Ian Rickson, who I’ve worked with for the last three shows since Let England Shake. I'd done music for his plays, and I found it so fascinating watching how Ian would direct the actors, but how he’d lean into what they were naturally doing and enhance the strength of that. So I began working with Ian on my show. Ian would come to the rehearsals, he’d listen to the demos of the songs, and he’d start to feel the emotional thread that was going through them. Being a theatre director, he thinks a lot in narrative – the narrative arc of this night, of this hour-and-a-half performance. He helps me find a way through that. He would watch what I naturally wanted to do in terms of singing and movement, and he would enhance what he thought were the good bits, tone down the bits that he thought were the bad bits, and get me connecting with the band regularly.
DJ Did he direct you in the movements as well?
PJH For instance, I was opening with my hands going like this (gestures). I was naturally doing that. But then he’d do things like, “Where is your head looking? Are you looking up? Are the hands going up? Looking down? Looking to the side? Drawing within yourself?” I love working with him, and I love the world of theatre. But just going back to dance as well, I think of all the other mediums of performance, I get the most inspiration from dance. I think it’s because there are no words, and I love that my imagination is set free by what this performance is saying to me with no words. It’s just saying it with bodies, music, set design and lighting, and it’s making me feel something really intensely. No one’s telling me what to feel.
DJ It’s a space of freedom, I would say. That’s also very much true for me. I think I would not have become a choreographer if I hadn’t followed the logic and principles of contemporary dance, because I’ve always had an issue with the very dogmatic and extremely strict nature, for example, of ballet. Even though I ended up working with ballet later, there’s something in me that really doesn’t connect with the way I see dance and why I love it. I love the fact that dance can be a place that invents its own rules. It’s an incredibly difficult process as well, but there is a sense of freedom that I love in contemporary dance. Maybe because it is so tuned in, it also merges with music. It’s such an intimate relationship with music because it plays with space and time in ways that mean you can basically reinvent it. You reinvent your relationship to it. I really use that non-dogmatic, non-traditional opportunity that was there, and that’s why I left theatre to go into dance, because I saw that there was this space of freedom that could be created.
PJH For me, I think the greatest reward is when I’ve taken a lot of time, care and love, and tried to make something as good as I possibly can, and then see how much it brings to other people. When you see how much people are physically moved by it, how much it enters their lives and changes them, there’s no better feeling than knowing that something I really tended to and cared for can do that for others. I think when we’ve made a piece and it goes out into the world, it’s no longer ours. It goes out for the people who are going to come and see it. It’s easy to ask yourself, “Why am I doing this?” Sometimes you can think, “What is this for? How important is it as an artist?” We live in today’s world where politics are governing the way we operate, and for the likes of you and me, as artists, we don’t get to have a lot of sway in how people run our world. And yet we keep trying to make these pieces of work that touch people and move people. Is our hope, when we’re talking about water and the waves, that these ripples of our small-scale work, seen by relatively few people in the world, and possibly by people who already feel and think like us, are going to have any sort of impact on the wider world – the world that we might hope to affect and change? That’s a question for both of us.
DJ The butterfly effect of this thing – a very small thing – can have a tremendous impact, but you’re not necessarily aware of it. Now, with the internet, certain things go viral and spread and get seen by a lot of people. The thing that is closest to the scale of what you’ve experienced during your whole career was the thing I did recently with Yung Lean, where suddenly I could feel that the whole world was enthusiastic about what this dance was conveying.
PJH That’s amazing, that the work you did with him, which started on such a small level, reached so many people. I find that so exciting, and that’s still the hope that I think I have inside.
DJ I was really surprised by how many people it touched, and how deeply. It’s just three minutes of movement and a song. But I think music, dance and literature, especially at this time when we feel incredibly threatened as a civilisation, but also as a species, because we’re dealing with incredible challenges that no generation before us has experienced, mean that art takes on even more of that role now: to remind us what is at the core expression of our soul. It connects again to the Voyager and this idea that what they sent into space as a first signal for aliens to see of us, is music. That tells me everything, in the sense that this is the core of our soul. Dance comes maybe a little bit after, or maybe quite a lot after. It’s so ephemeral. I think I’m really jealous of musicians, who have this sense of waves. You are tuned into invisible waves that can be accessed everywhere, at any time.
PJH We both try to make work that is about the world that we all share. We’re not just making intimate pieces about ourselves. We’re looking outwards because we care, and then the care that we take at that inception level of the idea ...
DJ It’s like a virus. It can be transmitted, that’s why you say something is going viral. I was in Japan during the earthquake in 2011, and I learned a great lesson there, because the Japanese were so incredibly calm throughout the whole apocalyptic situation. I remember each time there was an aftershock, we foreigners were like, “Oh my God!” We were running and trying to check what was happening; we were in complete panic, while they remained incredibly calm. I thought, as much as panic is contagious, calm and dignity are as well. We should never forget that we have that ambivalence inside of us, and there is constantly a question of how we can transmit values that are actually going to make things better.
PJH I think that’s a brilliant thing to say, and I think that’s also the hope that we carry in the work that we make: that it will resonate and affect people in that way, and move people towards a different path, maybe.
DJ For me, when I got into the lyrics of your new song, I felt an incredible sense of connection. To come back to when we met, I literally received a message from your manager when I was in Japan saying, “PJ Harvey would like to invite you to her concert.” I was like, “Wait, does PJ Harvey know me?” I couldn’t really process it. But then, when we actually met, you told me that you had come to see my shows five years before. I was so stunned. I thought, “How was I not aware that you were there and that you had so discreetly come to see the work?” Then we started talking about the work I was doing on Carl Sagan and Planet, and then we talked about Voyager and Tim Hecker. You told me that you loved Tim Hecker and that you were really interested in the Golden Record on Voyager. I was like, “Wow, these are incredibly specific interests.” So when I listened to the song “Voyager” I thought, “Wow, it really portrays something that I truly went through when I was making that work.” I think this idea that Carl Sagan had – to put these records on a spacecraft so that an extraterrestrial entity could intercept them and eventually receive a portrait of humanity through music – is incredible. It’s so poetic, yet it was conceived by scientists, and it’s so transcendent as well. For me, the discovery of the Golden Record profoundly inspired the process I went through on Planet, because I was looking for fossils, in a sense, for how we could give a perspective on humanity from another point of view than the one we have now. Sometimes we can get that perspective by studying history, finding fossils of previous civilisations, or even looking at life from billions of years ago. There’s this fascination that humanity has, but also this need that humans have to wander and go beyond their own borders, and the nostalgia that humans had when they finally went to the Moon. Then you look at the pale blue dot and feel that everything we know is contained on this very limited planet, while the rest is basically a void, and life itself is in jeopardy everywhere. I felt that this was an incredibly relevant point of view to have nowadays, given the time we are living through as humans. We’ve done so many things, but we’ve also caused so much harm, with a sense of unawareness about where we come from and our place within a very fragile web of life. How did you compose that song, and how did it become that incredibly emotional crescendo?
PJH I was already, as you know, really interested in our place within this enormous universe when we first met, and I think naturally, as you get older, you think about those things more. At this time in my life, I really wanted to learn about astrophysics and our solar system. I’m fascinated by finding out more, and in doing so, discovering how tiny we are, and how briefly we’re here. There’s something very humbling about that, in a really good way, when you’re living your daily life. Just remember that every day. I was already on that trajectory when Brian Cox asked me to write a song for his new live lecture. He asked me to write it as if I were Voyager 2, as if I were the voice of Voyager 2 speaking to the people on Earth based on what I had seen, and I loved that idea. He came up with it because when he first asked me about making a song, I was already writing music for my new album, and there were a few pieces I wasn’t sure were quite right. I thought I’d see if Brian liked any of them because I didn’t think I was going to use them. One of those pieces was made on a synthesiser, and it had a signal that was a bit like Morse code, or like a signal being sent back to Earth. That made Brian think of the signal from the Voyager 2 spacecraft and the way it sends information back to us, and because he talks a lot about the Voyager space probes in his lecture, he thought it would be perfect. So that’s how it began. But I’d already done a lot of research because I had basically watched and read everything that Carl Sagan had done, so I knew a lot about it already. I think it’s wonderful that he pushed through to get the Golden Records put on those spacecraft. How beautiful that there was this desire to send something from our world out into possibly nothing, but the desire was there to show a little bit of who we are and how we communicate. I love that there were greetings from all across the world, and especially the one spoken by Carl Sagan’s son. It was so intimate and yet so vast, all at the same time. The song flowed from me because I was already so deeply into the subject, and then being given the challenge that it had to be this voice and this spacecraft somehow, with those limitations, made it much easier to write because I knew exactly what I had to work with. It seems to me that you’re forever travelling, forever working really hard in stressful environments. Do you find it stressful, or do you thrive on it? Does it actually energise you?
DJ Well, in a way, it’s like a ritual. It creates a kind of bracket in time, and within that time it gives you pressure. In a sense, I try to use that as something that activates my resources and my imagination. It’s a little bit like the conversation we’re having now. Out of this conversation, certain ideas emerge.
PJH I think we both agree that we’re not quite sure where ideas come from. This fascinates me, because I know where the drive comes from. We both have the drive to make. We make stuff, and we have to make things. There’s really no question about it. I think you feel the same. Where does that come from? Personally I really don’t know, and I don’t know if you do either. Let England Shake was during the time of the Iraq War and the Afghan War, and I was watching a documentary about a young soldier who had been so badly damaged that he would never be able to continue his life. It was an intimate documentary about how that had affected him and his family, and there was something about this man and his family that moved me to tears. I remember crying while watching it. At the time, I was trying to think, “What am I going to write about next?” I’d come off White Chalk, which had been a very intimate album. I knew I wanted to go in the opposite direction. I wanted to move somewhere further away from that, to do something different. I wanted to look out into the world, and I thought to myself, “Polly, if you’re this moved by watching this, write about that.”
DJ Well, I think it’s so interesting because what you’re describing is that you took as a departure point where the previous album had brought you, and then you thought, “No, I want to move out of that situation.” You contextualise everything from that. I mean, every work I do is an exploration. I become aware of certain aspects of a condition through the creation itself. When you create a work, you start... it’s like a prism. You watch everything through a certain glass, a certain perspective. My last creation was actually called Prism. Through that exploration, there are a lot of things you discover, and those eventually lead you to take certain directions in your work. For example, when we did Vessel with Kohei Nawa, it emerged first from a desire to really work with him. He was my departure point. There was something I found so fascinating in his work, and then he agreed to collaborate. Basically, he started finding what I created incredibly inspiring for his own work, and that’s why I love collaboration. In a way, it emerges a bit like what we’re doing now, from a conversation. One thing leads you through the conversation, and you start understanding what the nucleus of a common interest is.
PJH I think it’s also how we find each other. You know, I reached out to you because there was something in your work that moved me so much that I felt I had to meet you. I had to meet this person because it felt like a compulsion.
DJ It’s very interesting, this contrast between seeds of ideas that emerge in an intimate life and then become so universal. I love exploring the subconscious. I try to pay attention to ideas that sometimes emerge in the moment between when you fall asleep and when you wake up. I always think of it like this idea in Tarkovsky – that we come from the sea as organisms, that our origin is there, in water. Water moves in a very specific way. I think one of the most inspiring movements for me is water because it’s constantly shape-shifting. It can freeze; it can be extremely quiet; it can be incredibly violent. It’s literally the main component of our life. Even if we don’t live in water, we still carry it like vessels. I find this really interesting because water is often seen as a symbol of death. There’s this idea of crossing a river when you die in so many mythologies, and at the same time it’s also considered, scientifically, the cradle of life. So I find this metaphor incredibly inspiring, and I think when you wake up, it’s a little bit like arriving ashore. Suddenly, you were in that kind of wavy environment, and you became conscious. I always take the image of someone who comes out of an ocean and wakes up, and you have a bit of that feeling of, “Oh, you get back to your body.”
PJH Yeah, I agree. I think coming out of sleep is like emerging from being underwater. But also, the images that you get in that halfsleep, half-awake state are so rich for creating with. I’m sure you’re someone who remembers every dream you have, don’t you?
DJ No, I don’t.
PJH You don’t?
DJ Do you?
PJH Yes! I don’t take notes. I never write a song out of dreams, but I remember every dream vividly.
DJ I know if I dream vividly, and I know I can have very emotional dreams, things that really get to your core. What I have sometimes is that, when I sleep and I’m falling asleep, my physical memory – the smell of the pillow, the horizontality – brings me to the dream of the previous night. It’s like a physical memory. It’s interesting that when you take the same position, when you feel the same texture, suddenly your body brings it back.
PJH That’s so interesting. I love that you said that because, and being a dancer, you would. You’re right. I have to get into the same position every night to feel safe enough to go to sleep, and I’ll wake up in the same position. That’s something really primal, I think, and goes right back to the womb – needing a feeling of safety to let yourself lose consciousness.
DJ It’s also the idea that gravity, when you fall asleep, that’s literally falling. You surrender. It’s one of the only moments when you have to let go.
PJH Apart from having sex.
DJ Yes, but even love – you can also fall in love and you can crash in love. And ultimately, sex is obviously when you really surrender. But, for example, it’s impossible to have sex in space. Did you ever hear that?
PJH Why?
DJ Because there’s no gravity.
PJH Oh, so you know what? I think that would be the funniest comedy sketch ever: to see two people in space trying to have sex.
DJ Nobody has done it yet.
PJH That’s really interesting. I think both of our work has a lot of sexuality in it. We’re absolutely right in that I think there’s nothing more vulnerable, including sleep, when you have to surrender consciousness. Where do we go? We go into this place where we have no control, and yet sex and intimacy can be like that too.
DJ So, just to finish this thing with ideas, I think David Lynch said that you need to compare ideas to fish, that you need to go and catch the big fish.
PJH Catching the big fish.
DJ So, that idea again – there is a connection. I think the subconscious moves like an ocean in a way, and I really see that sometimes when we allow ourselves to plunge into it. There are different ways of doing that. For example, if you think of altered states of consciousness, which are basically ways of reaching the subconscious, sleeping would be one of the greatest moments of surrendering to it. But daydreaming, when you’re suddenly looking into the void and starting to think of something that absorbs you, is another. It’s not something that you see; it’s something that you see beyond, or that you imagine. It’s somehow a way to connect yourself to that world. So I think it has to do with something like that. I’ve always been surprised that a lot of ideas emerge and sometimes I just have to catch them, but it’s not me that produces them.
PJH Yeah, I think David Lynch was talking about that because of his transcendental meditation as well. Through meditation, when you lose the boundaries of consciousness and set yourself free, I think that’s where you can go fishing for ideas. But you have to free yourself into it, like what you’re saying about daydreaming – giving yourself permission to let your brain swim freely without being hemmed in by our usual, agitated worries about the past or the future. I think it’s something that you can learn, and I know David Lynch was a practising meditator. You can learn a better way of finding your ideas through that. But I do think it’s really powerful, and it all comes back to consciousness and how we allow it or disallow it.
- TheNightingale
- Confirmed User
- Posts: 588
- Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2016 2:23 pm
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
The bit about her writing stuff through collaborative improvisation with Nils Frahm is very interesting and I’m curious to hear what results it will yield (assuming it makes it to the album). Great that she’s trying to break out of her default mode of recording guitar/piano demos at home and bring them to John & Flood.
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
Am I the only one who wishes she would ditch the ultra choreographed approach of Ian Rickson? not gonna happen anytime soon, I know!TheNightingale wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 7:15 pm The bit about her writing stuff through collaborative improvisation with Nils Frahm is very interesting and I’m curious to hear what results it will yield (assuming it makes it to the album). Great that she’s trying to break out of her default mode of recording guitar/piano demos at home and bring them to John & Flood.
new pic posted on her socials
- TheNightingale
- Confirmed User
- Posts: 588
- Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2016 2:23 pm
Re: PJH LP11 — updates & speculation
I mean, I really like the more theatrical staging aspect that Rickson has brought to her shows (the mood lighting, the backdrops, the old furniture on stage etc.), but I wish they would chill a bit with PJ’s overly literal choreography that sometimes consists of just pantomiming the song lyrics lolRomario11 wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 8:15 pmAm I the only one who wishes she would ditch the ultra choreographed approach of Ian Rickson? not gonna happen anytime soon, I know!